Some people argue that too many people go to college these days. High school grads sign up for community college without the necessary academic skills, and others go to a state university and drop out before they graduate. It’s a waste of their time and money, these people argue, and it’s a waste of taxpayer money as well.

It shouldn’t come as a surprise that this is a big argument in right wing circles that advocate for spending less money on education. It’s one of the Goldwater Institute’s favorite higher education topics. But that shouldn’t matter. The question is, do too many people go to college? Are they wasting their money, and ours?

According to a column in the Sunday NY Times, the answer is no. A college education makes a difference, especially for students who graduate but even for those who don’t. Obviously, there are plenty of anecdotal examples of people who were lousy high school students, then excelled in college—the column has a good one—but the column cites a few studies indicating that marginal students attending a four year college earn more than similar students who don’t.

I’m always skeptical of education-related studies whether I like their conclusions or not, but the studies mentioned in the column look better than most. They compare two groups of people with almost identical SAT scores, but one group just made the cutoff for getting into certain colleges — an 840 SAT score — and the other group just missed with an 830. There’s no discernible difference between students within that 10 point spread, so when you compare where they end up, it’s reasonable to say the college experience was part of the difference.

[T]he two studies have come to remarkably similar conclusions: Enrolling in a four-year college brings large benefits to marginal students.

Roughly half of the students in Georgia who had cleared the bar went on to earn a bachelor’s degree within six years, compared with only 17 percent of those who missed the cutoff, according to one of the studies, by Joshua S. Goodman of Harvard and Michael Hurwitz and Jonathan Smith of the College Board. The benefits were concentrated among lower-income students, both studies found, and among men, one of them found.

[snip]

Perhaps most important, the data show that the students just above the admissions cutoff earned substantially more by their late 20s than students just below it — 22 percent more on average, according to the Florida study, which was done by Seth D. Zimmerman, a Princeton economist who will soon move to the University of Chicago. “If you give these students a shot, they’re ready to succeed,” said Mr. Zimmerman, adding that he was surprised by the strength of the findings.

The takeaway from these studies, if they’re accurate, is that we should encourage people who want to attend community college or university to make the leap, even if their qualifications are marginal. Once they arrive, every effort should be made to help them graduate, but even if they don’t, the experience gives them a leg up on similar high school grads who don’t take the next educational step.

This article appears in Apr 30 – May 6, 2015.

9 replies on “The Value of Going to College”

  1. Don’t tell Bill Gates, Steve Jobs or half the billionaires in the US. You might give them a complex.

  2. Don’t tell Bill Gates, Steve Jobs or half the billionaires in the US. You might give them a complex.

  3. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is spending millions of dollars helping community colleges across our nation for the purpose of supporting under prepared students and helping them. Gates knows the value and importance of education in today’s world. To educate yourself on the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, check out their website. You might learn something: They value all education including college.

  4. Bill went to Harvard. Yes, he left early but that’s not to say he didn’t learn anything. Jobs also went to college, just didn’t complete. Besides they’re both geniuses and are silly examples to use to guide policy for the vast majority of us ordinary mortals.
    It’s sad that the ‘value’ of college is always given in economic terms anyway. The main value of a liberal Western education is an enlightened citizenry.

  5. What can be wrong with furthering one’s education, ever? Learning is essential to continue to grow and be a valuable part of society. I think the ‘argument'(which to me is only a bid to have people not think for themselves) is ridiculous. A education not only gives you more information, it also gives you more critical thinking skills that can be used to look at many sides of an argument. I see no downside to higher education.

  6. Altruistic views aside, it comes down to who is going to pay for it. High school graduates that can’t read or write do not instill confidence in the taxpayer asked to fund a waste of time and money. Efforts would be better spent “fixing” K-12. Thirty years of back sliding needs to be halted.

  7. It is interesting the higher unemployment for advanced degrees; could it be they have become too smart to work? Kinda like too big too fail?
    As I read the study I found it similarly parallels another program that runs 4~6 years, the military. An great VocEd program with pay & benefits Okay, so you might need to wear a school uniform but I have always said there are really only two groups you can be involved with that have such a strong bond. What other groups have reunions?
    Personally, I NEVER took the SATs, just went and paid my money and took the courses. Yeah, it took a little longer but no worse than the six years they mention here.
    Good article, thanks David.

  9. The value added by a college education has become more debatable, especially with soaring “for profit” prices and terrible long-term debt. But nobody but nobody ever lost self esteem by graduating and getting a degree – or a high school diploma, or a middle school promotion, etc., etc. It is one of those self rewarding moments that no one else can take away from you. They may mock you, but you earned something that sticks to your insides forever.

Comments are closed.