- State Sen. Al Melvin (R-LD26)
Republican state Senator Al Melvin declined a challenge by his Democratic contender, Cheryl Cage, to a series of one-on-one debates before the November general election, saying he can’t fit it into his schedule.
“I told her I’m busy,” Melvin says. “I’m going door to door.”
Cage, who lost the Legislative District 26 Senate race to Melvin in 2008 by fewer than 2,000 votes, says she thinks Melvin won’t debate her because he would have to defend his “abysmal” voting record.
“I mean, it’s completely against what the voters of LD26 want,” she says. “He voted for payday loan people to stay in business and 63 percent of our constituents voted against that. He voted 100 percent of the time against public education and we passed Prop 100 by a two-to-one margin.”
- Democrat Cheryl Cage
Though the two will not debate one-on-one this election season, they will attend several candidate forums alongside other legislative candidates in the coming months.
Besides those chances, Melvin says the voters can learn about the candidates on their own.
“I would encourage people to look at her website and look at my website,” Melvin says. “You know politics is education—there are many different ways for the voters to see the positions of the candidates.”
But you won’t be seeing Melvin’s position on KUAT’s Arizona Illustrated or in the editorial pages of the Arizona Daily Star and the Arizona Republic.
Melvin says he and other southern Arizona Republican lawmakers are issuing a boycott of the major local media outlets until the news organizations hire at least one “center-right” person to their editorial boards.
“They’re totally slanted to the left,” he says. “There is nothing fair and balanced about it and we’re not going to be a party to it.”
Though they are still talking to reporters from the papers, Melvin says they will not have anything to do with the editorial boards—and will not participate in endorsement interviews.
“The outcome is so obvious from the beginning that it makes no sense for us to participate (in the endorsement process),” he said.
This article appears in Jun 17-23, 2010.
I have attended several of his Senator Melvin’s forums, and heard a concerned parent at one address a number of his education ‘facts’ that were completely untrue. She was very polite, but Melvin just turned to her and said “What do you education people want, anyway??”
She was a parent with a kid in one of the LD26 schools. I don’t know if that makes her “education people” or not, but I agreed with her that he didn’t answer her questions, and that it was difficult to proclaim to be supporting his area schools when he voted against funding them 100% of the time in 2009.
On his webite, Senator Melvin has a ‘fact sheet’ about K-12 funding that contains all sorts of suspect information. The statistic “funding per classroom of student” doesn’t actually exist on any national surveys. He lauds ACT/SAT scores as evidence of AZ student achievement, even though few students take these tests (and the College Board that administers the tests has strong warnings on their websites urging people not to use the rankings in the way Melvin is trying too).
He also includes the widely debunked Goldwater invention of $9,700 per student funding (they used a revenue number which includes around $300m in lunch money, over a billion in day care & after-school activity payments by parents, etc. ) and numbers which appear to give AZ some high rankings (“Enrollment Growth Over 10 Years – 2nd!”) but actually make me question even more why he has worked so diligently this year to drain money from his own area public schools.
Sure would be nice if some rag-tag band of local media misfits that didn’t make it onto Melvin’s “major local outlet” list would dig into his claims a little further….(hint, hint)