Presented in its entirety, here is an op-ed entitled “R.I.P., Boy Scouts of America” by Matt Barber, who can be found on Twitter @jmattbarber.
“What good is it for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul?” (Mark 8:36)
It’s a sad day for both Scouting and for freedom. Indeed, it’s a sad day for America. The century-old Boy Scouts of America (BSA) — created in 1910 to “prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetimes” — has betrayed its own constituency, mission, oath and law.
Last Thursday, approximately 1,400 adult BSA delegates from around the country gathered in Texas and decided, in a disgracefully lopsided vote, to welcome into its ranks, “open and avowed” homosexuality (boy-on-boy sexual attraction and behavior), thereby disavowing the “morally straight” Scout Oath its members are sworn to uphold.
They voted unwisely.History will reflect that on this day the BSA turned from morally straight to immorally bent — that this once great organization — founded on “honor,” “reverence” and biblical morality — was crushed beneath the worldly weight of pagan idolatry.
Whereas, for over a century, millions of boys have raised their right hands, swearing “on my honor” to “do my duty to God and my country” — on this day, hundreds of adult delegates likewise raised their right hands, shook their fists at God and flipped their middle fingers at both the boys they serve and the parents who trusted them.
While endeavoring to “gain the world,” this once honorable institution has forfeited its soul.
Scripture admonishes: “The wages of sin is death.” (Rom. 6:23). This was a catastrophic miscalculation. It was sin, and, tragically, through this sin, the BSA has now effectively sealed its own fate. It has set into motion its own demise.
Even by its own estimates, BSA leadership admits that the decision will likely result in a mass exodus from Scouting. They anticipate that as many as 400,000 Scouts and Scouters will leave the organization (acceptable casualties in the war on morality, I guess). Still, as devastating as this number is, it too represents a gross miscalculation.
Consider, for instance, that when Canada’s version of the Boy Scouts voted in 1998 to welcome open homosexuality, its membership rolls plummeted by over half in just five years, forcing camp closures, staff layoffs and huge budget cuts. Looking north of the border for clues, then, we can expect that, with current membership at around 2.6 million, it’s more likely that roughly 1.5 million Boy Scouts and troop masters will walk.
Then again, we’re talking about “progressive” Canada. This is the good ol’ USA. With over 61 percent of Scouts, Scouters and parents opposing the homosexualization of Boy Scouts, and over 70 percent of U.S. Scout groups sponsored by churches and religious organizations, it’s not unreasonable to expect that defections will even exceed this estimate.
In short, BSA’s betrayal may well result in near-total ruin. The wages of sin is death.
Here’s the reality: Reality has not changed. Objective truth did not suddenly and miraculously reverse itself on May 23, 2013. As BSA has always acknowledged (until Thursday), homosexual behavior remains empirically disordered and immoral. The only thing that has changed is politics.
Ultimately, this decision had nothing to do with “tolerance” or “inclusivity.” Neither did it concern the best interests of the boys who make up Boy Scouting. Instead, this decision was rooted in pure evil. It had everything to do with money. “For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. Some people, eager for money, have wandered from the faith and pierced themselves with many griefs” (1 Timothy 6:10).
And wandered from the faith they have.
Now come the many griefs.
Really, three things drove this decision: Fear, greed and politics. A number of high-dollar corporate donors threatened to pull funding from BSA if they maintained the existing policy on sexual morality. Additionally, a number of extremist pressure groups, aided by a sympathetic left-wing media, brought tremendous pressure to bear.
But the pressure’s not going away. The BSA made a critical error in judgment. It showed weakness. This has only whipped these radicals into a heightened frenzy. Within moments of the “gay” announcement, Nancy Pelosi called the move “an important first step.” The Human Rights Campaign demanded “the new policy doesn’t go far enough,” and Mother Jones, a liberal online publication, posted an article titled, “Boy Scouts: You Can Be Gay Until You’re 18.”
Sin is never satisfied. The homofascist thirst for absolute affirmation is unquenchable.What’s the next step? Activists now demand that adult men who desire sex with other males (“gay” scout masters) be allowed to take your sons camping overnight. Soon they’ll be insisting that “transgender boys” (girls who wish they were boys) be allowed to join as well.
What a camping trip. Imagine the pup tent. Your son and Jimmy — who’s got a crush on him — along with Billy and Billy’s boyfriend Bobby, all snuggly warm in the middle of nowhere. But make room for Sammy (formerly Suzie) and Sammy’s boyfriend Gary (formerly Gertrude).
Don’t forget to hang the disco ball.
And “always be prepared.”
You think there won’t be new membership stagnation? Who wants to sign their boy up for the “Gay Scouts”? What’s a kid gotta to do to earn his “tolerance badge”? Parents, you might want to get out while the gettin’s good. As one Eagle Scout told me, “I’m not leaving the Boy Scouts, the Boy Scouts left me.”
It’s only a matter of time until BSA caves on these demands as well. They’ll admit “gay” men and girls soon. They have no choice. Now that they’ve opened the door, they’ve waived the only legal defense they once had: religious and moral conviction.
But here’s the good news. I and dozens more will be convening for a coalition meeting of pro-family leaders next month in Louisville, Ky., to discuss the creation of a moral alternative to the Boy Scouts. Nature abhors a vacuum. We intend to fill it.
Still, until then, please join me as we mourn the loss of this once honorable organization. The Boy Scouts of America: Born Feb. 8, 1910 — Died May 23, 2013.
May it rest in peace.
This article appears in May 23-29, 2013.

So if we’re quoting Scripture: “Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.” or how about “Judge not lest ye be judged.”
I’ve always thought that if the numbers are correct about the percentage of men being homosexual that would mean that at least one or two or maybe three Apostles were gay.
And if we’re talking Fascism I thought they were in general a pretty intolerant group of people….sort of like you, Matt.
And what the hell is a Scouter?
The thing that bothers me so much about these so-called “moral” people is that they continue to insist that the BSA is a Christian, Biblical organization. It’s not and it never has been in my lifetime. The first Muslim I ever met was in Scouting. Ditto for the first few Hindus and *GASP* the first Atheist. Without any doubt, I probably met some gay boys as well, but they were made to hide what is a major part of their psyche so they could be scouts. Modern boys will be able to embrace their own personalities and be Scouts.
I think that is a very positive thing.
So which is it? The organization will die because of the mass exodus of anti-gay scouts and their families, or the decision was driven by a hunger for money (which comes in with membership, no)?
Also, love the use of “objective truth” and “immorality” in the same paragraph. There is nothing objective about the word “immoral.”
Thank you for posting the OP Ed. I had no idea that gay folks were not ethical and moral.
I will now be on the look out. I don’t want any dishonest people around here!
tell me Matt, how is it doing your duty to God and being morally straight when you sign your name to something you didn’t write? The whole screed is plagiarized- it’s all over the wingnutsphere. I’d rather have my kid hanging out with a gay kid than a liar and a cheat…
This guy is a chode
Hey Buddy: get a life, seriously, A grown man worried about boy scouts and homosexuality? Something tells me you have a thing for both, to be so damn concerned with it.
Homosexuality is like smoking: you should be able to put anything you like in your body by dint of simple ownership. Your body is yours to do with as you please, the bigoted dictates of some illusory Hebrew tribal deity or crusading body Nazis notwithstanding.
Matt is still in the closet, obvsly.
Hey Matt – It’s not looking good for your Creative Writing Badge, but your Bigotry Badge is in the bag!
I wonder how it feels to be representative of a prime reason why an ever-increasing percent of the population checks the “none of the above” box when asked about religious preference?
1. If the Boy Scouts of America have decided they are a “Christian” organization that excludes certain people due to their sexual orientation, then they are, to my mind, no longer a “non-profit”. Instead, they are a private organization not open to all.
2. Being Gay, Bi, Transgendered, or Hetero has nothing to do with morality. Within each group there are a large majority who are very moral in their lives and the usual small percentage which are not. Morality has to do with beliefs, perceptions and behavior.
3. My husband, an Eagle Scout, has written many letters and responded to many emails stating he will no longer have anything to do with the Boy Scouts unless or until they open their organization to all.
Those who seem to feel their particular beliefs are right and science and everyone else are wrong are free to have any organization they want – just not to enjoy non profit status.
My personal definition of “abnormal behavior” is that which is shown by heterosexual males that have such an intense and passionate interest in homosexuality.
A scouter is an adult leader or volunteer.
Common on Matt! Are you a goofy homophobic? What happened pal? Did some Webelo scout bite you weenie on an overnight sleepover?
Reading the comments reveals a pattern of name calling and subject changing, rather than respectful, thoughtful or logical discussion. Matt, I did not appreciate the condescension, but at least you barely avoided the slew of insults (repressed, closet gay, bigot, homophobe, fascist, unfair, etc) that most commenters listed. How sad for scouting, the free expression of (good) ideas, and respectful public discourse.
Barber started the name-calling with “pagan idolater”, “betrayer”, “morally bent” etc…I’d say he used a fair number of insults and did nothing to further a reasoned discussion or respectful public discourse. So, judge not…