Courting History

Local Painter Jim Waid's Making A Federal Case Of Public Art.

By Margaret Regan

JIM WAID IS at work on the biggest painting of his career. In his backyard
studio in Menlo Park, 10 huge canvases lean against the austere white walls. Waid has been working on the sprawling panels on and off for over a year, covering them with his characteristic loose paint strokes, gyrating plant shapes and hyped-up desert colors.

"The actual size is almost to the scale of a human being," Waid said on a recent afternoon so hot that the temperature nearly matched the yellow heat in his painted desert. "A lot of things have to be different as I blow (the study) up."

Review Each canvas measures five feet wide by nine feet high; hinged together, they'll make a nine-foot-tall painting that stretches 50 feet long. Its 450 square feet may not sound like much if you're talking real estate, but that's a mighty big space for acrylics to cover. But we are talking real estate. The painting is destined to hang in the new federal courthouse now under construction in downtown Tucson. When it's completed next summer, the massive Evo A. DeConcini Federal Building and Courthouse, named for the late real-estate mogul, Arizona Supreme Court justice and father of ex-Senator Dennis, will soar to about 140 feet, the equivalent of 11 stories, occupy a gigantic L-shaped footprint at the corner of West Congress Street and Granada Avenue, and will measure about 413,000 square feet.

"There were an obvious number of places in the building where the art might go," Waid said, "and one was a big wall in the lobby of the Granada Avenue building." The painting will be installed there, facing the Catalina Mountains to the north, above a balcony and staircase meant to mimic the mountains' switchbacks. (A sculpture by California artist Lita Albuquerque will go up in a courtyard.)

Waid has done few public art commissions in his career, and he thinks "only in the most general way" about the future audience for the work--the judges and jurors, the guards and suspected drug dealers. He's more concerned about aesthetic and technical questions: How much does he need to heighten the colors, to exaggerate perspectives, so the image works from the lobby floor as well as from the balcony? Will the panels match up when they're in place? Should the work be an abstracted landscape of the desert, or a more realistic illusion of depth?

"I want to create a painting that enhances the light and space," he said. "It's a joyful painting."

BUT IF WAID creates the beautiful work of art he intends, it will be a happy ending, sort of, to a typically tortured Tucson development story. The commission was awarded by the General Services Administration, the real-estate branch of the federal government, through its Art-in-Architecture Program. Dating back to 1963, the program is a clear descendant of New Deal programs that had artists painting heroic murals in post offices all across the country. The hotly contested courthouse, an $81-million federal project, is going up on land near Tucson's birthplace along the once-marshy Santa Cruz River. Once prime agricultural fields, the tract later evolved into a transportation hub, sheltering stables and overflow activity from the old El Paso & Southwestern Railroad. Later it was occupied by Carl Hayden Hospital, which was razed in 1979, a decade after urban renewal that laid waste to the surrounding barrios. Owned by developer Allan Norville, the acreage stood empty for years.

In the early 1990s, Norville proposed a convention hotel, exhibition hall (particularly for the Gem & Mineral Show), offices and retail shops for the site. But the federal government had other plans. Property the feds already owned on East Congress, between Stone and Scott avenues, was deemed too small and too insecure for a federal courthouse in the wake of the Oklahoma City bombing. Some city council members and arts types thought a location at Stone and Alameda would be beneficial to downtown revitalization, and they were miffed when a public hearing on the subject seemed designed to muffle dissent.

The feds were intent on four of Norville's acres for their new building, and when he turned up his nose at their $1.93 million offer, they condemned it. At a jury trial in early 1997 to determine the price, federal lawyers made the not very tactful argument that they shouldn't pay much because Tucson's desolate downtown wasn't worth much (one lawyer talked of the city rolling up its sidewalks at night). Local though they were, the jury sided with the feds and gave Norville only $2.7 million. But on appeal late last year, another jury gave Norville $8.39 million, a sum that Tucson boosters immediately judged to be a sign of confidence in the downtown's re-emergence.

Along the way, Don Diamond lobbied against the project, since it will pull a bevy of rent-paying federal offices out of La Placita, which Diamond owned at the time. The Congressional Republicans' budget-conscious Contract with America was another threat. The project finally prevailed, but not without engendering a lot of hard feelings locally.

MEANTIME, WAID WAS keeping an eye on all the turmoil. "I got the commission in the spring of '96, but the GSA told me, 'Don't order your stretchers yet, we're having a funding problem,' " Waid remembered. "I was worried. Then I had the museum show at TMA (Tucson Museum of Art, in November 1996) and I got the stretcher bars when the museum show opened."

To prepare for what may well be his summation of all that he's tried to convey about the Sonoran Desert in his art, Waid did a lot of hiking in Saguaro National Park West, where he sketched and photographed, and read natural history by the likes of Gary Paul Nabhan.

"Basically, this is a desert landscape that's more or less abstracted...I want it to have a canyon wall feeling. I'm in an argument with myself, whether it should be a literal entering-in kind of space. I'm not sure whether the shallow space might be better. Right now I'm trying to push the literalness."

Waid works on as many of the panels at once as he can, usually at least three at a time. Despite the vast size, he's adhering to his typical working method. First he applied "dark brownish purple over the whole thing," then did a thin white sketch, using a brush tied to bamboo pole to get some distance from the surface. After that, he laid in big patches of color.

"It's still relatively loosely painted," he said. "I'm laying things in and taking things out."

Photographer David Burckhalter has documented the making of the painting from start to finish; it may be another year before the end is at hand. Despite three studio visits from GPA officials, Waid said he's not overly conscious of Big Brother looking over his shoulder.

"I couldn't have done it If I hadn't been able to do my own style," Waid said. "The great tragedy of public art is that artists can be forced to do things not in their general realm...Or committees are striving to be so fair and democratic you get everybody's second choice."

Why do public art at all?

"That's like asking, 'Why do art?' It's a basic impulse. In Europe you go to look at the Sistine Chapel...Nobody's going to come look at our architectural legacy. I'd like to see more grandeur in our public spaces."

Once his painting is in its new public space, just a mile east of his home, Waid said he hopes to be able to make some final touches in situ. And after it's done, he imagines he'll visit a lot, though he hopes he won't be like Bonnard, the French painter found trying to touch up one of his paintings in a museum when it was some 20 years old.

The big desert painting, of the much-loved local landscape, rendered by one of the town's most respected artists, might be some compensation for locals still angry about the disputed courthouse. For Waid, at least, it's a wonder that as long as the building is there, "the painting will be there. It feels great." TW


 Page Back  Last Issue  Current Week  Next Week  Page Forward

Home | Currents | City Week | Music | Review | Books | Cinema | Back Page | Archives


Weekly Wire    © 1995-97 Tucson Weekly . Info Booth