Style and Substance 

'Public Enemies' takes historical liberties, but presents John Dillinger's life in captivating fashion

Crime-film maestro Michael Mann goes back to the '30s for his latest film, the characteristically hypnotic and moody Public Enemies. Johnny Depp does amazing things as John Dillinger, the infamous bank robber who should've opted for a nice summer drive rather than a movie on a hot night in 1934.

Mann continues to be a master of stylistic crime drama. Public Enemies stands alongside his Heat, Collateral and Manhunter in the genre.

Depp, even though he is 15 years older than Dillinger when he died, is right at home in the role. Anybody who has seen Dillinger's smirk in old photos will know that Depp has nailed the man's look and attitude. And when Dillinger is seen displaying his menacing smile as he watches Clark Gable in Manhattan Melodrama just moments before being gunned down, you can see Depp reveling in the moment. Dillinger probably related to the goings-on in the last movie he watched, and Depp eerily portrays this.

Aside from the Depp performance, the most notable thing about the film involves the shootouts, and there are plenty. Mann actually did a night shoot at the location of the legendary Little Bohemia Lodge gunfight. I'm thinking folks associated with this film are going to get nominated for some sound Oscars, because the thud of bullets hitting trees in the forest is appropriately frightening. Mann also went to great lengths to depict Dillinger's two prison breakouts, and shot at the actual jail in Crown Point, Ind., where the gangster carved a fake gun out of wood and used it for his escape.

Mann and his fellow screenwriters take plenty of artistic license when it comes to historical accuracy. Notorious criminals such as Baby Face Nelson (Stephen Graham) and Pretty Boy Floyd (Channing Tatum) die before Dillinger in the film, but actually outlived the man in real life (although they all perished in 1934). There's actually a very odd moment in the film when Dillinger meets FBI agent Melvin Purvis (played by Christian Bale) and calls him the man who got Pretty Boy Floyd. History tells us that Floyd was still alive at the time being depicted.

It's easy to forgive the historical inaccuracies. It's also easy to forgive actress Marion Cotillard for slipping into her French accent during a prison torture scene. Cotillard, who plays Dillinger girlfriend Billie Frechette, is a fine actress who might need to work on that American accent a little more. Still, her work as a Wisconsin girl taken in by Dillinger's charms is captivating.

While Depp might be the main attraction here, the work of Bale as the determined Purvis is just as powerful. The script gives the man an exaggerated role as far as bagging bad guys is concerned, but Bale's depiction of the crime fighter (made all the more interesting because he is, indeed, Batman) is haunting.

If the movie has a major fault, it's that it tries to jam too much into its running time. J. Edgar Hoover, as portrayed by Billy Crudup, could've used a little more screen time. Mann seemingly avoids much of the controversy that plagued Hoover's early career, including his animosity toward Purvis. In this film, Hoover is basically portrayed as an ornery boss who talks like he should be announcing a Chicago Cubs baseball game.

These are mere quibbles. The film is one of the year's best so far, and it gives us another chance to bask in the greatness of Depp and Mann. No doubt, there are many other movies that could be made about the multiple figures in this film. As for showing us what Dillinger was about, Public Enemies completes this task with style and substance.

Public Enemies
Rated R · 140 minutes · 2009
Official Site: www.publicenemies.net
Director: Michael Mann
Producer: Kevin Misher, Michael Mann and G. Mac Brown
Cast: Johnny Depp, Christian Bale, Marion Cotillard, Billy Crudup, Stephen Dorff, Stephen Lang, Channing Tatum, Stephen Graham, Giovanni Ribisi, Jason Clarke, David Wenham, Emilie de Ravin, Lili Taylor, James Russo, Rory Cochrane and Branka Katic


More by Bob Grimm

  • All in the Family

    Alfonso Cuaron’s Roma is a moving look at a nanny’s sacrifices
    • Dec 13, 2018
  • Road Show

    Green Book is an OK movie but it should have aimed higher
    • Dec 6, 2018
  • True West

    The Coen Brothers go to Netflix with The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
    • Nov 29, 2018
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Girl Power

    It takes an Amazon to rescue DC Comic’s lackluster movie universe
    • Jun 8, 2017
  • Ghosts of Christmas

    Charles Dickens wrestles with the spirits of the season
    • Nov 30, 2017

What others are saying (8)

The Coast Halifax Seven magnificent faces of Johnny Depp In honour of Public Enemies, we compiled seven videos of the enigmatic star’s most popular looks. What’s your favourite Depp role? by Sue Carter Flinn 07/02/2009
Memphis Flyer Outlaw Heroes Public Enemies is an artful take on the classic gangster film. by Chris Herrington 07/09/2009
Colorado Springs Independent Opening this week Away We Go; My Sister's Keeper; Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen 06/25/2009
5 more reviews...
The Coast Halifax Depp impact As gangster John Dillinger in Public Enemies, Johnny Depp plays yet another unlikely character. We survey the beloved actor's darkly compelling roles. by Hillary Titley 07/02/2009
Chicago Reader History vs. Hollywood Though adapted from a zealously factual book, Public Enemies takes the usual liberties. by J.R. Jones 07/02/2009
Colorado Springs Independent Johnny be good This film is not a history, but a fantasy, mostly having to do with the durable gangster-glamour of the movies, boiled down to a vision of two elegant men on opposite sides of the law. by Jonathan Kiefer 07/02/2009
Colorado Springs Independent Opening this week Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs; Public Enemies; Whatever Works and more. 07/02/2009
The Coast Halifax Public Enemies sometimes dangerous Michael Mann's film is good, brilliant at times, but doesn't sustain the dazzle to be called a truly great film. by Hillary Titley 07/09/2009

The Range

Three Great Things to Do in Tucson Today: Tuesday, Dec. 18

New Year's Party Preview

Three Great Things to Do in Tucson Today: Monday, Dec. 17

More »

Latest in Cinema Feature

Facebook Activity

© 2018 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation