So-So Circus 

'Water for Elephants' is an enjoyable yet unspectacular film

Set in a Depression-era circus and featuring some decent performances, Water for Elephants is good enough to recommend—but nothing to get super-hyped about.

If you like elephants, and you like Reese Witherspoon movies, have at it. If you'd rather be golfing than watching a Reese Witherspoon movie, book your tee time now.

The film moves along at a pleasant-enough pace and features a central Robert Pattinson performance that is endearing, if not all that amazing, and a Reese Witherspoon performance that, while not remarkable, is better than anything she has done in years. The movie is helped by a villainous performance from Christoph Waltz, now Hollywood's go-to guy when a good scumbag is needed.

If this doesn't sound like high praise ... well, it's not meant to be. This story of a forbidden love affair under a circus tent is the very definition of passable entertainment. I was slightly moved by it, and I sort of liked it a little bit. That's all.

In a role that isn't much of a departure from Edward Cullen, Pattinson plays Jacob, a veterinary student who loses his parents to a car crash. When the bank takes the family home, he jumps on a train and winds up doing hard labor for a ragtag circus run by August (Waltz), who is slightly crazy. The star attraction is a horse ridden by August's wife, Marlena (Witherspoon).

Pattinson looking forlornly at the married Marlena reminded me of his puppy-dog yearning for Bella in the Twilight movies. He has the lovesick routine down just fine—but perhaps he should pick a project that has him playing with toy trains or trying to win a regional soccer championship next time. He needs to cheer up and do something different on the big screen.

As for his chemistry with Witherspoon, it's nearly nonexistent. They are not convincing as a couple, and their interactions are rather flat, with most of the lubby-dubby tension coming from the Pattinson side. Witherspoon is seemingly traipsing through the role with little effort. Still, this is better than the confused performance she threw out there for last year's awful How Do You Know.

Waltz, who is in danger of becoming typecast, brings his all to the role of August. His character seems to have been underwritten a tad in Richard LaGravenese's script. At times, it looks as if Waltz is trying to make August somewhat sympathetic, but it's not enough to make August a fleshed-out, conflicted character. His nice moments are more of a distraction than an indication that August might have real depth.

The true star of the movie is an ancient elephant (named Rosie in the film) which is nothing short of beautiful. I love that elephant look when the mouth is open, and it seems as though the elephant is laughing at the silly humans around it. This could have been two hours of Rosie doing tricks and drinking people's booze, and I would have been equally satisfied.

Director Francis Lawrence (I Am Legend) has made a visually impressive film, capturing the splendor of the circus while not avoiding the fact that the operation is a bit rundown and starved for cash. The movie is framed Titanic-style, with an old Jacob (played by Hal Holbrook) telling his story to a modern-day circus operator (Paul Schneider). Old pro Holbrook gives the movie some of the emotional punch it needs.

Water for Elephants reminded me of the circus-viewing experiences I had when I was a kid. The animals were kind of cool; the people were a little boring; and the show went on a bit too long. Still, there was always something at the circus worth seeing. I was sort of glad I watched the film, despite its shortcomings.

Water for Elephants
Rated PG-13 · 121 minutes · 2011
Official Site: www.waterforelephants.com
Director: Francis Lawrence
Producer: Gil Netter, Erwin Stoff, Andrew Tennenbaum and Kevin Halloran
Cast: Reese Witherspoon, Robert Pattinson, Christoph Waltz, Paul Schneider, Jim Norton, Hal Holbrook, Mark Povinelli, Richard Brake, Stephen Taylor, Ken Foree, Scott MacDonald, James Frain, Sam Anderson, John Aylward, Brad Greenquist, Tim Guinee, Donna Scott and E.E. Bell


More by Bob Grimm


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Ghosts of Christmas

    Charles Dickens wrestles with the spirits of the season
    • Nov 30, 2017
  • No Wonder

    Justice League is a big step back for the DC movie universe
    • Nov 23, 2017

What others are saying (4)

The Coast Halifax Elephant the best thing in Water for Elephants Sarah Gruen adaptation "a slog" by Molly Segal 04/21/2011
Boise Weekly The Projector: Movies opening Friday, April 22 A traveling circus, French monks and Samuel L. Jackson narrating the lives of some really big cats, it's all at the movies. by James Ady 04/22/2011
Style Weekly Elephant Men Robert Pattinson carries the weight of the circus on his brow in "Water for Elephants." by Wayne Melton 05/03/2011
1 more review...
Charleston City Paper Halsey curator Mark Sloan helps inspire Water for Elephants Water for Elephants, released last month, is based on Sara Gruen's best-selling 2006 novel of the same name, which in turn was inspired by Charleston's own Mark Sloan. by Jansen Cumbie 05/10/2011

The Range

24 Great Things to Do in Tucson This Weekend: April 19 to 21

Eight Great Things to Do in Tucson Today: Thursday, April 18

Laughing Stock: Overstock!

More »

Latest in Cinema Feature

  • Ain’t Worth a Damn

    Without del Toro, this franchise goes straight to hell
    • Apr 18, 2019
  • Reel Indie

    Films to see at Tucson's indie theaters this week
    • Apr 18, 2019
  • More »

Facebook Activity

© 2019 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation