Selfish Stubbornness 

'White Material' is a well-done yet puzzling war movie

Director Claire Denis has made an astonishing, puzzling war movie with White Material, featuring a haunting central performance from Isabelle Huppert.

As Maria Vial, a French woman in an unnamed African country shattered by civil war (the year is also not revealed, but the film has a modern feel), Huppert exhibits a quiet stubbornness. When French Army helicopters fly over Maria's coffee plantation, and soldiers tell her it's time to get out for her own safety, she refuses; it seems at first that she simply doesn't realize the danger she and her family could be in. However, Denis slowly reveals in captivating fashion that Maria has completely lost her grip on reality.

Denis brilliantly stages her movie out of order, starting the movie with characters, who will play big parts in the ensuing film, dead and dying. It's a risky move for any filmmaker to show you their ending first, but Denis and company pull it off.

Maria's once-prosperous family now wanders about their gutted plantation in a post-traumatic haze. Her ex-husband (Christopher Lambert of Highlander and Tarzan fame) is trying to sell the plantation behind her back and flee. Her troubled son, Manuel (Nicolas Duvauchelle), sleeps most of his life away, only to be harassed by rebel children when awakened—after which he goes completely around the bend. And her father-in-law now does little more than take baths and sloth around the house.

Each of these weak-willed men paints a pretty good picture as to why Maria has withdrawn into herself and resists authority. Socially, she's alone (although the movie hints at an affair with another character), and the plantation is all she has.

Huppert never has a moment in this film when she seems to be overdoing it or slips out of character. Her Maria is stubborn to a fault; Denis never spells out in words why Maria refuses to leave her plantation for the safety of her homeland—because Denis doesn't have to. The answers are entirely in Huppert's expressive face, her increasingly disillusioned behavior and the behavior of those around her.

There are many echoes here of Apocalypse Now, with Maria's journey ultimately feeling a little like that of Martin Sheen's Willard in the Francis Ford Coppola epic. Those who have seen Apocalypse Now Redux (Coppola's "director's cut") know about the reinstituted scene involving a French plantation in the middle of the Vietnam War, in which a family refuses to leave their land. This film almost plays out like an extension of that very scene, simply moved to a new location and time.

One could say that Denis' film is about basic human nature when faced with the atrocities and confusion of war ... and one would probably be wrong. Most people would run for the hills once rebel children showed up on their property leveling machetes, yet here, such actions only serve to make Maria stick around.

The movie, more than anything, is a testament to human selfishness, and how obsession with the self and one's material belongings can lead to total devastation. Perhaps Maria has been mistreated and neglected in the past, but that is no excuse for her actions. Maria is given a series of choices, and she makes all of the wrong ones. The plantation has become her identity, and she refuses to let it slip away. Given the tragedies that result, there's nothing heroic in her decision to stand pat.

Yves Cape's artful camerawork and the sonic soundtrack by Stuart Staples help make this film an all-around rich experience. For future films, Denis would do herself good to keep them nearby.

White Material
Rated NR · 105 minutes · 2010
Director: Claire Denis
Producer: Pascal Caucheteux
Cast: Isabelle Huppert, Isaach De Bankolé, Christopher Lambert, Nicolas Duvauchelle, William Nadylam, Adèle Ado, Ali Barkai, Daniel Tchangang and Michel Subor


More by Bob Grimm


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Ghosts of Christmas

    Charles Dickens wrestles with the spirits of the season
    • Nov 30, 2017
  • Stop the Bourne-ness

    Jason Bourne is the latest in a franchise that needs to end immediately … please
    • Aug 4, 2016

What others are saying (3)

Portland Mercury Coffee Time White Material: Picking at the scabs of colonialism. by Alison Hallett 12/16/2010
Indy Week A West African colonial nightmare in White Material In White Material, the latest from French master Claire Denis, the fantasy of colonialism confronts the nightmare of armed rebellion. by Nathan Gelgud 01/05/2011
Boise Weekly The Projector: Movies opening Friday, March 4 Whether you're in the mood for a step back into the '80s or to see a cartoon lizard with Johnny Depp's voice, it's all at the movies. by James Ady 03/04/2011

The Range

Two Dozen Ways To Have Fun This Weekend!

The Weekly List: 25 Things To Do In Tucson This Week

Comedy, Beer, Theater & More: Eight Things To Do Today!

More »

Latest in Cinema Feature

  • Of Inhuman Bondage

    Our critic could use a safe word to get him out of having to review this hot mess
    • Feb 15, 2018
  • Reel Indie

    Where the reel fun happens.
    • Feb 15, 2018
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • Of Inhuman Bondage

    Our critic could use a safe word to get him out of having to review this hot mess
    • Feb 15, 2018
  • More »

Facebook Activity

© 2018 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation