Cruel and Unusual 

Paul Rudd and Steve Carell deserve better material than they get in 'Dinner for Schmucks'

Dinner for Schmucks isn't a total clunker; it's got some decent laughs thanks to its two main stars, Steve Carell and Paul Rudd, who do the best they can with the material they've been handed.

Unfortunately, that material is marred by large stretches of uncomfortable humor. There are moments of true inspiration; alas, those moments aren't enough to put this one over the top.

Rudd plays Tim, a man trying to climb the corporate ladder. After the poor bastard above him is fired, Tim seizes the opportunity and finds himself in line for a promotion and a sweet office. There's one catch: In order to be promoted, Tim must attend an annual dinner with his company's head honchos—and he must bring an idiot to the gathering, because the honchos use the occasion to mock their special guests, and award the prize of "biggest idiot" when the evening is over.

This premise is pretty cruel, but potentially funny nonetheless. Tim hedges at first, mainly because his girlfriend, Julie (Stephanie Szostak, who has teeth that kind of interrupt her dialogue in that cute Hilary Swank sort of way), doesn't approve.

But fate intervenes when Tim hits Barry (Carell) with his car. Barry was in the middle of the road collecting a dead mouse for his quaint, self-created collection of stuffed mice in panoramic settings.

Barry is very strange. Tim realizes this—and he has his dinner guest.

Almost immediately, Barry dispatches hellfire on Tim's personal life. He inadvertently invites a crazy ex-girlfriend (Lucy Punch) to Tim's apartment after a computer-sex chat, and this leads to overall badness. It also leads to an awkward restaurant scene that represents the film's low point—a point from which it never really recovers.

Schmucks does a lousy job with most of its female characters. Punch's Darla is a travesty of a characterization that stops the film in its tracks whenever she's onscreen. Szostak's Julie is a whiny party-pooper who is portrayed as nothing but a pain in the ass. Her job as an art curator puts her in contact with Kieran (a horribly mistreated Jemaine Clement), a strange artist who would never achieve any level of success anywhere but in a stupid movie. Julie's allegiance to this artist makes her look clueless and severely lacking in credibility.

The dinner scene itself is good for some laughs—and even a few gut-busters. Zach Galifianakis stops by as one of the idiots, and he's always good for guffaws. Carell's Barry displays all of his prized mice, including a Benjamin Franklin one with a kite plugged into a socket ... because it is an electric kite. This scene is the movie's best, but you have to wait a long time for it.

Carell's performance reminds me of his hilarious and moronic Anchorman role (Brick). He fully immerses himself in the guise of Barry, and he's the best reason to see the movie. His mouse creations are actually quite genuine and touching, especially the one that depicts an aspect of his failed marriage. At times, it's hard to watch Carell mugging his ass off when Jay Roach's direction is so terribly flat. Carell deserves better.

Rudd also deserves better, as he's forced to play the straight man again. Rudd is one of filmdom's best straight men, but he's also capable of being the main laugh-getter, and that's what I hope to see him doing soon. I don't want another Paul Rudd film in which he is always reacting to other people being funny. I want more Wet Hot American Summer Rudd, where he's the funniest thing in the movie, and not resorting to shtick like the old "bad back" routine.

The attempts at humor often fall flat, and there's too much talent in this film for it to be flat for extensive periods of time. Although Dinner for Schmucks is not awful, it does stand as one of the summer's biggest disappointments.

Dinner for Schmucks
Rated PG-13 · 114 minutes · 2010
Official Site: www.dinnerforschmucks.com
Director: Jay Roach
Producer: Walter F. Parkes, Laurie MacDonald, Jay Roach, Francis Veber, Amy Sayres, Sacha Baron Cohen, Gary Barber and Roger Birnbaum
Cast: Steve Carell, Paul Rudd, Bruce Greenwood, Ron Livingston, Jemaine Clement, Jeff Dunham, Stephanie Szostak, Lucy Davenport, Lucy Punch, David Walliams, Zach Galifianakis, Rick Overton, Octavia Spencer, Larry Wilmore, Patrick Fischler and Andrea Savage


More by Bob Grimm

  • Space Junk

    This Predator dog don’t hunt
    • Sep 20, 2018
  • The Write Stuff

    Glenn Close shines but The Wife is a wee bit too melodramatic
    • Sep 13, 2018
  • Carnal Knowledge

    A new documentary explores the secret sex lives of Hollywood stars
    • Sep 6, 2018
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Girl Power

    It takes an Amazon to rescue DC Comic’s lackluster movie universe
    • Jun 8, 2017
  • Ghosts of Christmas

    Charles Dickens wrestles with the spirits of the season
    • Nov 30, 2017

What others are saying (4)

Portland Mercury Schmuck Hunting Dinner for Schmucks: Finally, a bromance with mouse taxidermy! by Alison Hallett 07/29/2010
The Coast Halifax Dinner for Schmucks uses the wrong recipe Paul Rudd and Steve Carell's latest is full of missed opportunities and bad choices. by Hillary Titley 08/05/2010
Memphis Flyer Eat Play Dumb Dinner for Schmucks for dummies. by Greg Akers 08/05/2010
1 more review...
Colorado Springs Independent Opening this week Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore, Charlie St. Cloud, Dinner for Schmucks and more. 07/29/2010

The Range

Tucson Storytellers: How Tucson Became Home

Dogs’ Adoption Fees Cut in Half: PACC Celebrating National Dog Week

Maroon 5 to Perform at the 2019 Super Bowl

More »

Latest in Cinema Feature

  • Space Junk

    This Predator dog don’t hunt
    • Sep 20, 2018
  • Reel Indie

    Films to catch at Tucson's indie cinemas this week
    • Sep 20, 2018
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • Meathead Puppets

    The Happytime Murders is dead on arrival
    • Aug 30, 2018
  • Carnal Knowledge

    A new documentary explores the secret sex lives of Hollywood stars
    • Sep 6, 2018
  • More »

Facebook Activity

© 2018 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation