Brutality on BART 

Fruitvale Station isn't a fun film to watch, but it's a movie you shouldn't miss

Writer/director Ryan Coogler has made one of the year's best films with his bold feature-directing debut, Fruitvale Station. It tells the true story of Oscar Grant, the man shot to death by a cop on New Year's Eve 2008 while riding the BART with his girlfriend and mother of his child.

If you've seen the mobile videos taken of Grant pleading with officers for order as he and his friends were being brutalized in the BART station, you've seen the face of a man who looked more than reasonable as events transpired. As one cop turned him onto his stomach and put his knee onto Grant's neck, another inexplicably took out his gun and shot Grant once, fatally, through his back.

The officer claimed he was just trying to tase Grant. Mistake or not, it doesn't matter. That officer, without reason, took Grant's life while a throng of BART riders watched and filmed in horror.

Coogler could've made a justifiably angry film, screaming in the face of a justice system that cost this young man his life and his daughter a father. What he has made is something far more important, effective and nuanced.

He has made a movie that fleshes out Grant so that he's more than those few minutes captured on frantic people's phones. It's a movie that concentrates on the life taken, the people he loved, and the lives that were to be lived together that were taken away. It's a crushing, heartbreaking viewing experience anchored by a brilliant performance from Michael P. Jordan (Chronicle) as Grant.

The film starts with the infamous phone footage of Grant's murder, and then flashes back to Grant and his girlfriend Sophina (the excellent Melonie Diaz) having a fight about Oscar's alleged infidelity. He's a man on a stumbling recovery from a prison stay, trying to keep his job, raise his daughter Tatiana (Ariana Neal) and make his mother Wanda (Oscar winner Octavia Spencer) proud.

It is Wanda who suggests Oscar and Melonie take BART on New Year's Eve to celebrate safely, and it is Wanda who realizes this as she says goodbye to her son's corpse just a few hours after celebrating her birthday with him. Spencer makes this a scene you will not soon forget.

While the film does start with the mobile footage of Grant's death, Coogler and Jordan do recreate the tragedy at the end of the movie. They portray Grant the way he appeared in those cellular phone videos: just a guy caught up in an unfortunate situation, trying to be reasonable with the police in order to get himself and his friends home for the new year.

By the time this plays out, we already know what happened, making every second of the sequence as unbearable as it should be. The cop who shot Grant is already walking free after serving a one-year sentence for involuntary manslaughter. Coogler pulls no punches in depicting the abhorrent behavior of those cops.

Jordan delivers a graceful, star-making performance, the type of work that will put him on a lot of good directors' radars. As portrayed by Jordan, Grant has his problems, including a temper that sometimes gets him into trouble. A jail scene where Wanda comes to visit Grant that ends with him pleading to his mother while guards swarm him is one of the film's most memorable.

Coogler and Jordan plan to work together again on Creed, a Rocky spin-off that see's the grandson of Rocky Balboa's former opponent looking to Balboa for guidance in his boxing career. Stallone has shown interest in the project, and it looks to be a go. It sounds like fun.

As for Fruitvale Station, I expect this movie will get some notices come awards season. It's the kind of movie that makes a mark on you, an important film about something that should've never happened, and a movie everyone should see.

Fruitvale Station
Rated R · 85 minutes · 2013
Official Site: www.fruitvalefilm.com
Director: Ryan Coogler
Producer: Forest Whitaker, Nina Bongiovi, Michael Chow, Lisa Kleiner-Chanoff, John Kwok and Octavia Spencer
Cast: Michael B. Jordan, Octavia Spencer, Melonie Diaz, Ahna O'Reilly, Kevin Durand, Chad Michael Murray, Joey Oglesby, Laurel Moglen, Liisa Cohen, Ariana Neal, Alex Garcia, Noah Staggs, Caroline Lesley and Christina Elmore

More by Bob Grimm

  • Flunked Out

    Melissa McCarthy is not applying herself in Life of the Party.
    • May 17, 2018
  • Cinema Clips: Revenge

    • May 14, 2018
  • Birth Pains

    Tully explores the exhausting challenges of motherhood
    • May 10, 2018
  • More »


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Ghosts of Christmas

    Charles Dickens wrestles with the spirits of the season
    • Nov 30, 2017
  • Walking Tall

    Antoine Fuqua gets all magnificent, again
    • Sep 29, 2016

What others are saying (9)

Indy Week Fruitvale Station speaks to post-Trayvon Martin America It's a sad state of affairs when movies like Fruitvale Station have to show everyone what they should know by now: Black people are people, too. by Craig D. Lindsey 07/24/2013
Creative Loafing Tampa Fruitvale Station is powerful real-life drama Ryan Coogler's assured directorial debut is the best movie of the summer. by Mitch Perry 07/25/2013
6 more reviews...
The Coast Halifax Fruitvale Station Michael B. Jordan's likability intensifies an already intense film by Tara Thorne 08/22/2013
Style Weekly Life After Death Move Review: "Fruitvale Station" resurrects the tragically shortened life of Oscar Grant III. by Nicholas Emme 08/06/2013
Memphis Flyer Domestic Drama The brief wondrous life of Oscar Grant. by Greg Akers 07/25/2013
Humboldt Insider Risky Stunts Counselor is tired, Grandpa is spry by John J. Bennett 10/31/2013
Portland Mercury A Day in the Life Fruitvale Station and another dead black man. by Denis C. Theriault 07/24/2013

The Range

The Weekly List: 23 Things To Do In Tucson This Week

Laughing Stock: Laff’s and Tears, Plus New Mics

More »

Latest in Cinema Feature

  • Flunked Out

    Melissa McCarthy is not applying herself in Life of the Party.
    • May 17, 2018
  • Reel Indie

    What to watch this week.
    • May 17, 2018
  • More »

People who saved…

Facebook Activity

© 2018 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation