534 N. Fourth Ave.
Let's hear it for the little pizza parlor that could! Brooklyn Pizza Company has come out on top over the big guys across the street (who still make a solid pie, BTW). This unassuming shop on Fourth Avenue cooks up a classic pizza pie, with the classic toppings, for a classic price. You'll think you're in Flatbush with your first bite.
Runners up:
2. Rocco's Little Chicago
3. Magpies Gourmet Pizza
