Favorite

¡Ask a Mexican! 

Dear Mexican: What's with calling yourselves La Raza? Being Mexicans, Chicanos or whatever isn't enough--now you're THE race? Sounds pretty racist to me.

The Race is On

Deart Gabacho: Few things annoy the Mexican more than the Know Nothing Nation's deliberate ignorance with this most nebulous of Mexican idioms. Despite the patient explanations of Chicano yaktivists who say the phrase doesn't exclusively mean "the race" in Mexican Spanish, but is a synonym for "community," idiot commentators insist that "la raza" alludes to a Mexican sense of racial superiority akin to Nazism and white supremacy. No group gets the brunt of criticism more than the National Council of La Raza (NCLR), one of the largest civil-rights groups in the United States, and one in the news recently, because both John McCain and Barack Obama addressed the organization during its recent national convention. Professional pendejos like Michelle Malkin hissed a fit, calling the NCLR seditious and accusing the two presidential candidates of legitimizing hate by visiting them--all this over two Spanish words.

Betcha they've never read the primary source from which "la raza" originated--José Vasconcelos' 1925 booklet, La Raza Cósmica (The Cosmic Race). Vasconcelos, Mexico's first secretary of public education, wrote his piece as a reaction to the race thinking of the time, one dominated by adherents of Darwinism and Herbert Spencer's "survival of the fittest" prism that placed the gabacho above all people. The Mexican intellectual also subscribed to racial stratifications, but whereas others saw unavoidable strife, Vasconcelos imagined something greater. La Raza Cósmica is a classic work of the prophetic tradition, one in which Vasconcelos predicted humanity would evolve into a fifth race, free of the negative attributes each racial group possessed, to create a harmonious existence--the cosmic race, la raza cósmica. Crucially, Vasconcelos never stated Mexicans were that race, but rather wrote that Latin America's legacy of mestizaje posited "Ibero-Americans" as prime acolytes to spread the gospel of fusion--not through violence, but "the triumph of fecund love."

The raza cósmica theory is utopian and even goofy--but it's ultimately an anti-racist dream. Vasconcelos was by no means perfect--he didn't like ugly people and was too fixated on the superiority of Spanish qualities--but his ideal is one not that removed from that American standby, the melting pot. He even understood the humanity of gabachos--"The exclusion of the Yankee (from la raza cosmic), like the exclusion of any other human type, would be equivalent to an anticipated mutilation, more deadly even than a later cut."

Needless to say, Vasconcelos' theory gained fans across Latin America. But it wasn't until the 1960s Chicano movement that the concept of la raza cósmica gained further followers. Like most things they took from Mexico (food, women, the language), Chicanos corrupted Vasconcelos' vision, interpreted "la raza" as referring exclusively to Mexicans and forgot the whole brotherhood bit.

"It is true that mestizaje is one of the central concepts of the Vasconcelos essay," states the introduction to Didier T. Jaén's excellent translation of La Raza Cósmica, "but, of course, it is also clear that the racial mixture Vasconcelos refers to is much wider, much more encompassing, than what can be understood by the mestizaje of the Mexican or Chicano."

Like Vasconcelos, the Chicano definition of "la raza" was rooted in its turbulent time. It was during this era that the organization that preceded NCLR incorporated that term into its name in 1972. But over the decades, the cósmica part of la raza was largely dropped, as was the ethnocentrism, and what remained was a benign synonym for Mexicans.

People can disagree with NCLR's policies, but to classify them as the Tan Klan because of their name is like a prude getting offended over the name of the titmouse. By the way: Don't paint me as an NCLR apologist. I think the organization's president, Janet Murguia, is stupid for trying to get right-wing pundits off the air, mostly because they're so easy to prove wrong. Besides, the only raza that truly matters is mine: the Nerd race. Por mis Nerds todo; fuera de mis Nerds, nada.

More by Gustavo Arellano

  • Come to an Adios

    Many of ustedes must be scratching your heads right now. "What happened to ¡Ask a Mexican!" you're preguntando yourselves.
    • Oct 26, 2017
  • Ask a Mexican!

    Dear Mexican: I'm very bothered by the fact that Tom Flores is not in the Hall of Fame.
    • Oct 12, 2017
  • Ask a Mexican!

    Dear Mexican: With all these NFL players kneeling for the national anthem, how do the Mexicans feel about this?
    • Oct 5, 2017
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

  • Ask a Mexican!

    Dear Mexican: Math problem: If there are 20 Mexicans, 20 Indians, 20 Chinese, 20 Puerto Ricans, 20 Blacks, and one white person on a room, then how many people are there in the room who's identity is used as a benchmark to establish the identities of the rest of the people in the room? (Hint: not a colored person.)
    • Nov 17, 2016
  • Danehy

    Tom is just waiting for the day when a tattooed kid sics a dog on him in a grocery store for asking too many questions
    • Jun 23, 2016

Latest in Ask a Mexican!

  • Come to an Adios

    Many of ustedes must be scratching your heads right now. "What happened to ¡Ask a Mexican!" you're preguntando yourselves.
    • Oct 26, 2017
  • Ask a Mexican!

    Dear Mexican: I'm very bothered by the fact that Tom Flores is not in the Hall of Fame.
    • Oct 12, 2017
  • More »

Most Commented On

Facebook Activity

© 2017 Tucson Weekly | 7225 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation