Here's why critics love 'Killing Them Softly,' while audiences hate it

Patience Required 

Here's why critics love 'Killing Them Softly,' while audiences hate it

As I watched Brad Pitt's Killing Them Softly, from director Andrew Dominik, I sat in a virtually empty theater with a few friends and several other patrons. The movie is a slow, meditative and strangely beautiful examination of bad people, and I could sense it was testing people's patience.

I kept hearing the relentless "tap, tap, tap" of restless-leg syndrome coming from somebody behind us. I heard a lot (a lot) of deep sighing from the few people who were there, along with rustling as they fidgeted.

What I am trying to say is that Killing Them Softly requires great patience while viewing. This is a movie that takes its time, features more than a few wordy monologues, and has lots of poetic slow-motion shots.

Pitt plays Jackie, a smooth, shady type called upon to clean up a situation gone bad regarding an organized-crime card game. The film is set about four years ago; the country is in recession, and that recession has spread to crime. So when the card game—a big money generator—goes down, something has to be done.

The big card game is off due to a series of robberies at the games, some of them inside jobs, some of them not. People are going to die, and it's Jackie's job to make sure that it all goes off without a hitch.

The result is an interesting look inside what makes a crime syndicate tick. I enjoyed seeing Pitt's Jackie discussing his killing plans with a buttoned-up type (played by Richard Jenkins) while parked in a swank car.

I also liked seeing a hired hit man (James Gandolfini) drinking heavily and bitching about his wife—right before he's supposed to pull off an important job. Jackie, essentially his boss, acts like an antsy shift supervisor who knows the cash drawer is going to come up short when the bell tolls, because his employee is hitting the bottle.

Dominik previously made a movie in this same vein, and it even starred Pitt as another criminal type: The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford had a similar, meditative vibe about it. Audiences were split over that film's beauty and its slow pacing. Killing Them Softly is producing a similar reaction.

In a way, Jackie represents the sort of criminal Jesse James was in his day, although Jackie is hampered by modern problems regarding money and technology. Dominik uses speeches by Barack Obama and other political types as background noise, constantly reminding the likes of Jackie that the landscape is changing: When the average Joe is having trouble making a buck, it results in less money for stealing and paying hit men.

Ray Liotta endures what has to be one of cinema's all-time-worst beatings, full of blood, broken bones and vomit. I've read comments about how Dominik romanticizes or glorifies violence with some of his more-poetic killing sequences. Hey, the scene involving Liotta getting his clock cleaned more than balances things out. It's brutal.

Pitt is a movie star of the highest order, and every moment he spends onscreen in this film amplifies that point. Jackie is a despicable character, and while Pitt doesn't necessarily make him all that likable, he does make Jackie funny in a sinister way; he's always engaging.

I really liked the use of Gandolfini. I pictured his Tony Soprano all washed up, relegated to taking killing assignments and drinking himself to oblivion. No, he's not Tony in this movie, but I'm sure the connection wasn't lost on him or Dominik.

Critics like Killing Them Softly, while audiences are giving it an "F" (according to Entertainment Weekly's moviegoer polling). I guess that qualifies Dominik as a "critical darling"—and somebody who is going to have a hard time procuring big budgets for movie ideas in the future.

Killing Them Softly
Rated R · 97 minutes · 2012
Official Site: killingthemsoftlymovie.com
Director: Andrew Dominik
Producer: Brad Pitt, Dede Gardner, Steve Schwartz, Paula Schwartz, Anthony Katagas, Megan Ellison, Matt Butan, Bill Johnson, Jim Seibel, Adi Shankar and Spencer Silna
Cast: Brad Pitt, Scoot McNairy, Ben Mendelsohn, Richard Jenkins, James Gandolfini, Ray Liotta, Vincent Curatola, Slaine, Max Casella, Trevor Long and Sam Shepard

Trailer


Now Playing

Sorry there are no upcoming showtimes for Killing Them Softly

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

What others are saying (9)

Chicago Reader Money shots Brad Pitt and director Andrew Dominik team again on Killing Them Softly by J.R. Jones 11/28/2012
Indy Week Mobsters chase the American dream in Killing Them Softly Killing Them Softly is a portrait of an America ruled by avarice, where the have-nots are fraught with vice and the haves are left to jockey for an even bigger piece of the pie. by Neil Morris 11/28/2012
6 more reviews...
Colorado Springs Independent Super text: Killing Them Softly For a while anyway, Dominik has the makings of a uniquely down-and-dirty spin on familiar underworld material. by Scott Renshaw 11/28/2012
Arkansas Times A gangster allegory with no soul Brad Pitt's 'Killing' is bleak. by Sam Eifling 12/05/2012
The Coast Halifax Killing Them Softly An engrossing tale of greed and instability, just in time for the holidays by Jacob Boon 11/29/2012
Memphis Flyer Killing Them Softly Brad Pitt leads a rogue's gallery in ambitious crime flick. by Chris Herrington 11/29/2012
Portland Mercury American Gangsters Blood, money, and Killing Them Softly. by Erik Henriksen 11/28/2012
East Bay Express Killing Them Softly Pup fiction. by Kelly Vance 12/05/2012

Facebook Recommendations

Popular Events

More by Bob Grimm

  • Life in Dark and Light

    Roger Ebert's life story, told in the format he loved so much, is one of the year's best films
    • Jul 17, 2014
  • Complex and Confounding

    Paul Haggis might make a truly great movie someday, but Third Person’s not it
    • Jul 9, 2014
  • More »

Latest in Cinema Feature

  • Life in Dark and Light

    Roger Ebert's life story, told in the format he loved so much, is one of the year's best films
    • Jul 17, 2014
  • Rising to the Top

    Beyond the Edge looks at the conquest of Mt. Everest from a new (and 3-D) perspective
    • Jul 17, 2014
  • More »

Most Commented On

  • Troubled Train

    Snowpiercer's bleak look at a frozen future demonstrates that director Bong Joon-Ho is here to stay
    • Jul 3, 2014
  • Independence Inconvenience

    Obvious Child just doesn't have enough to sustain interest
    • Jun 26, 2014
  • More »

Top Viewed Stories

  • True TV

    • Jul 10, 2014
  • Rising to the Top

    Beyond the Edge looks at the conquest of Mt. Everest from a new (and 3-D) perspective
    • Jul 17, 2014
  • More »
Tucson Weekly on Facebook

Facebook Activity

© 2014 Tucson Weekly | 3725 Mona Lisa Rd. Ste. 125, Tucson AZ 85741 | (520) 797-4384 | Powered by Foundation